Economy-wide solutions are needed
Friday, January 18th, 2008Reporting for the USA Today, James Healey had the good fortune to test drive a Toyota Prius Plug-In hybrid prototype. Much of the article featured his impressions of the car which were quite strong. The car is capable of 7 miles of all electric driving before it switches to the usual gasoline-electric hybrid mode the Prius is synonymous with. The car does not use a lithium ion battery to hold electric charge, an impressive achievement that will only get better as battery technology progresses.
The interesting part of the article to me was this quote from Jaycie Chitwood, senior planner at Toyota’s advanced technologies unit in the USA. He was asked how the plug-in affected emissions and stated:
“Averaged across the USA, “There’s very little (emissions) benefit” compared with a current Prius hybrid”
This is the case because much of the power generated in the United States comes from coal and other fossil fuels which produce emissions upstream, at the power plant. While the car produces far less pollution the power plant that provides the electricity still pollutes.
This brings up a point that is often overlooked when discussing new green initiatives: solutions to climate and energy issues must be economy wide and not focused on a particular industry. The automakers can create a car that runs electrically, but without the power generators switching to greener energy sources then very little benefit is realized.
Saddling one industry with all of the responsibility is not a solution; it will take innovation across all sectors, each industry adopting the advanced technology that can make a difference. Any other approach is shortsighted and will not help to achieve climate change goals.